“We cannot tell for certain whether the words were written by John Florio or by William Shakespeare.“
It has been suggested by some Shakespeare’s scholars that The First Folio was a project organised by Ben Jonson and John Florio, alias Shakespeare.
In an article published in The Guardian, Saul Frampton set out a case that John Florio may have anonymously played a role in producing the first collection of the First Folio, the collection of plays written by Shakespeare. Modern scholars agree that actors John Heminges and Henry Condell, traditionally considered the Folio’s assemblers, were unlikely to have been entrusted with editing the expensive, 900+ page volume. Frampton quotes scholar Eleanor Prosser:
Frampton, author of a book on Montaigne (whose Essays Florio translated into English) and an upcoming work on Shakespeare and Florio, finds significant correspondences between words Florio used in his writings of the 1570s-1610s and revisions made to the 1623 Folio versions of Shakespeare’s plays. Frampton notes:
While earlier editions of many Shakespeare plays exist for comparison, about half the plays had never previously been published, and:
Eric Rasmussen, University of Nevada, in his article Who edited the Shakespeare First Folio?1 examined two possible candidates as editors of the First Folio: Leonard Digges and John Florio.2 Rasmussen ended his analysis by stating that he undertook this study intento upon “proving that Leonard Digges was a more viable candidate than was John Florio” but “the data, preliminary though it is, does not support this conclusion”:
Stuart Kells, Shakespeare’s scholar, in his book Shakespeare’s Library: Unlocking the Greatest Mystery in Literature, has suggested that The First Folio was edited by both Florio and Ben Jonson, describing John Florio and Ben Jonson as Shakespeare’s editors, “master polishers and serial neologists.”
Donatella Montini, Florio’s scholar, noted that:
“In 1620, John Florio translated Boccaccio’s Decameron anonymously. The printer, Isaac Jaggard, and the dedicatee, Sir Philip Herbert, Earl of Montgomery, will be the same protagonists of the publication, in three years time, of Shakespeare’s celebrated Folio.“
Writer and professor at Ca’ Foscari in Venice and at Hautes études Internationales et politiques in Paris, Jeremy Lester suggested that John Florio was not just the editor of Shakespeare’s First Folio, “but perhaps the author of these works himself? Might this explain why he had the temerity and the confidence to make wholesale changes in his editorial work precisely because he was at the end of the day editing his own work?”
A document that proves John Florio was involved in the production of the First Folio is a letter he wrote in 1623 to Lord Cranfield, Lord Treasurer, asking to have some money to “finish and publish my greate and laborious worke, for which my Contrie and posteritie so long as English is spoken, shall have cause to thank, and remember your Lordships Honorable name, that fostered the Muse of your most humble poor servant J. Florio.”
Some Florio’s scholars, like Miss Frances Yates, have erroneously tried to suggest that in this letter Florio is referring to his third dictionary. This is not correct for a great number of reasons: A note attached in the 1623 letter confirms that John Florio received the money he asked to Lord Cranfield, but he never published a third dictionary between 1623 and his death,1625. A third dictionary was published by Giovanni Torriano in 1659. In the preface, Torriano wrote that he had taken some of the pages published from Florio’s old draft. It is absurd to believe that John Florio, who asked to receive money in 1623, and received them in the same year, waited more than thirty years to release a third dictionary who wasn’t even published under his own name, but by Torriano, that in 1623 Florio didn’t even know personally. Furthermore, John Florio, in the 1623 letter, doesn’t cite the work as “dictionary”, he cites it as “laborious work”, implying an important task he had undertaken anonymously and couldn’t mention in a letter, perfectly knowing he was working as ghostwriter. This letter should serve as proof of Florio’s involvement in the editorship of the First Folio. The fact that he refers to the First Folio as “my greate and laborious worke” means without any doubt that he was revising his own work.